Posted by Kurt Johnston
A very simple tweet started some very interesting conversations. Yesterday I tweeted the following:
“Cancelled youth services two weeks in a row hoping families will go to church together…baby steps toward closing the generation gap.”
If you are a youth worker, you know that for the past few years, the hot topic in workshops, articles, books and around the water cooler is the failure of “modern” youth ministry. Apparently we have been doing it all wrong for them past 40 years and our methodology is soley to blame for the current state of Christian teenagers.
This rhetoric has been so dominate that I have assumed most churches and youth ministries have taken steps to change how they minister to students. After all, when most authors, speakers, professors and experts (MANY of whom do not minister in a local church setting) tell us we are doing it wrong, we are quick to course-correct, aren’t we? Certainly my cancelling youth services for two weeks in favor of families worshipping together would be met by yawns by my fellow youth workers. Apparently not.
There was a little interaction on my Facebook page and several messages and emails sent my direction that caught my attention. People were surprised I had the freedom to cancel youth group, people disagreed with my reasoning that it is good for families to worship together, others made the case for why age-based, specialized ministry is still the best approach, and a couple applauded my efforts.
Here’s the deal. I believe strongly in age-based ministry. I believe our “modern” approach to youth ministry still works, but needs a few tweaks. I refute the accusations that modern youth ministry alone is to blame for the ills our church-going teens face. But obviously creating a culture where teens and adults never rub shoulders is no good. Certainly, looking for ways to bridge the obvious generation gap in our churches, and finding ways to break down silos and build multiple-generational community is good.
It is obvious to me, and canceling youth group for two weeks was a simple thing for me to do. Apparently, it isn’t as obvious or as simple for others in the trenches.
Would love for you to share your thoughts.
Note: I am posting this from my iPad which doesn’t allow me to scroll back up to edit text or re-read what I have already written…so I will trust it was cohesive.